Catching Features

[OCAD]REVIEW

Open:08:00 Jan 20 2010
Close:08:00 Jan 27 2010
Map:/Holtalsasenutsnitttest/events/Holtalsasenutsnitttest/day1/Course0.course
Created by:SlaR
Description:This is just preparations before the much larger map will be launched. I would like to have reviews and comments about the forest, ground and running speed. Thanks for your opinion. WT ~ 1 min ;) /SlaR
Avg Rating:4.0 / 5.0 (34 votes)

Results

172 official (+189 reruns) hide comments

1. Olof Larén-Sandgren Sweden Växjö OK 1:19  *****
Speed settings are good, like the looks (even though the forest seems a bit odd), but the marshes are way too fast I think.Could be really awesome this thing.
2. mr Sweden OK Linné 1:20  
white forest is too even and gles
3. apnurmee Finland Kalevan Rasti 1:21  
3. Serg Doronin Russian Federation SneGoVik o-team 1:21  
3. KalleBergman Sweden OK Ravinen 1:21  
3. Daynee Sweden OLGY Slayers 1:21  
7. Bullen Sweden Suraarmaravtegel 1:23  
Comments: There is undervegetation on the semiopen area but not in the white forest, that feels odd. Marshes are not very marshlike, try other vegetation and groundcolour. Forest groundtexture is great. All trees are pretty much the same height, variate them and mix in some birches in variated heights.
7. RUSIA Guernsey monolit 1:23  *****
7. Daniels Sweden Attunda OK 1:23  
7. Kristo Estonia www.okilves.ee 1:23  
7. Andreas Hultqvist Sweden Tullinge SK 1:23  
7. OBT France KLS 1:23  
13. sundlof Sweden Gävle OK 1:24  
i think the wide pine tree shouldnt ever be used, its hitbox is not where everyone would like it
13. Eirik Norway NTNUI 1:24  
13. mansen Sweden GMOK 1:24  
13. Ida Mari Norway Kristiansand OK 1:24  
13. Ðóñåöêèé Ñåðãåé Ukraine 1:24  *****
13. Fredde Sweden nxtg 1:24  
13. rjm United States NEOH 1:24  *****
Green but pleasant forest, good textures
13. Jakenm Sweden Gävle OK 1:24  
13. Jakob Andersson Bhutan Bredaryds SOK 1:24  
22. HPM Norway NTNUI 1:25  
green a bit dense for my taste..
22. Matsubitsu Finland Vehkalahden Veikot 1:25  
22. Michael Granqvist Sweden OK Ravinen 1:25  
22. Êîðñàð Ukraine Monolit 1:25  
22. Challe Sweden Rehns BK 1:25  
22. Wejan Sweden OLGY Slayers 1:25  
22. MatteA Virgin Islands OK Tisaren 1:25  
22. Kreiberg Denmark OK Roskilde 1:25  
22. Jeremy G Belgium TROL 1:25  
31. Karl D Sweden OL-Teamet 1:26  
31. Hallmen Sweden OL4 1:26  
31. Tovisen Sweden Stora Tuna OK 1:26  
31. tjalvedu Spain TJALVE 1:26  
31. -=MoGiLaN=- Belarus O'Belarus 1:26  *****
31. Korik Ukraine 1:26  *****
31. Jochen Sweden GMOK 1:26  *****
31. Halvor Eid Nielsen Norway NTNUI 1:26  
31. Elxigo Antarctica SOL-BoyZ 1:26  
get higher speed in white forest. rest is prima, or maybe ugly trees in lightgreen... (a) lovely dark ground...
40. Pale Finland Vehkalahden Veikot 1:27  
40. Ben Sand France viking 1:27  
40. antonsson Bhutan Eksjö SOK 1:27  
40. Adriaan Pelckmans Belgium Trol 1:27  
44. PHJ65 Finland SuSe 1:28  
44. A.S.L. Lubina Germany TV Wattenscheid 01 1:28  
44. Simon Kappel Sweden Haninge SOK 1:28  *****
44. jeschke Austria OLG Stroeck 1:28  *****
Looks good, I like it.
44. HuggE Saudi Arabia SOL-BoyZ 1:28  
44. Robin Sweden FK Göingarna 1:28  
44. Galina Vinogradova Russian Federation CSKA 1:28  
51. BeN'O France COCS 1:29  
Perhaps too much features in marsh, green is identifable, white good too. ground nice for me. I usually add small tree to avoid far vision. Don't hesitate to make your own tree or remade old one, i use GIMP program, it's free and very usefull. Also you can find good tree at the CF library ! good luck
51. Knubbe Sweden OK Computer 1:29  
51. TC Sweden Malungs OK Skogsmårdarna 1:29  
51. Moa Sweden SNO 1:29  
51. Heggo Sweden OL4 1:29  
56. thiago Brazil Fuzileiros Navais 1:30  
56. Frzfrz Austria OJE Wappler 1:30  
56. Betak Czech Republic Kalevan Rasti 1:30  *****
56. kajari Finland 1:30  
56. eickhoff Sweden GMOK 1:30  
56. Skogsjonis Sweden Kexholms SK 1:30  
56. Hjojo Sweden OL4 1:30  *****
63. Acke Granbarr Sweden OLGY Slayers 1:31  
63. Jakob Schach Germany OC Schwaben 1:31  *****
63. engstrom Sweden OK Orion 1:31  
66. janands Norway Team Pez And Snapple 1:32  
66. Krasimir Bulgaria Trapezica 1:32  
66. T6nis Estonia Rakvere OK 1:32  
66. stevegregg United States BAOC 1:32  
66. furuczd Slovakia Farmaceut Bratislava 1:32  *****
66. Steph Clement-Agoni France TSO 1:32  
66. sparven Sweden IKHP 1:32  
66. Karschtl Germany USV TU Dresden 1:32  
66. Hollbeck Sweden Bromma-Vällingby SOK 1:32  
75. janof Slovakia Farmaceut Bratislava 1:33  
75. jeb France VSO 1:33  
75. yann France EMHM 1:33  
75. anhaktov Russian Federation Sportident.ru 1:33  
75. Mange Sweden FK Göingarna 1:33  
80. ShvedA Estonia MS Parma 1:34  
80. Björck Bhutan OK Älme 1:34  *****
82. LPasturiza Brazil COSaM 1:35  *****
82. Jonatan Estonia OK Võru 1:35  
82. Rulle Sweden IFK Göteborg 1:35  
85. Philipp Koch Germany OC Schwaben 1:36  
85. Anton Karlsson Sweden OK Kullingshof 1:36  
87. pedero Norway Nord-Østerdal OK 1:37  
87. DNF Sweden Stora Tuna OK 1:37  
87. TimZor Sweden Falköpings AIK OK 1:37  *****
87. Remitz Bhutan OK Orinto 1:37  
91. Steken Sweden IF Rigor 1:38  
91. Robin L Sweden FK Göingarna 1:38  
93. Klll Denmark neXus OK 1:39  
93. Vinogradov Mikhail Russian Federation Alfta-Ösa OK 1:39  
95. tio Pepe Sweden Kalmar 1:40  
95. nessie Sweden OK Ravinen 1:40  
95. Irdan Remark Germany Post SV Dresden 1:40  
98. honzau United States SDO 1:41  *****
It seems too dense and loads too slow compare to other maps.
98. Ilirej Slovakia Farmaceut Bratislava 1:41  
98. àëåêñàíäð Russian Federation êîíòóð 1:41  
101. Akva Ukraine Odessa 1:42  
101. BekAmk Russian Federation MTBO SPb Club 1:42  
101. Camel Slovakia Farmaceut Bratislava 1:42  
104. Joe Berg Sweden OK Älgen 1:43  
105. Boris Isaikin Russian Federation DINAMO 1:44  *****
105. Steffen Germany OC Schwaben 1:44  
107. andre de veirman Belgium trol 1:45  *****
107. Jonna Jungåker Sweden Korsnäs IF OK 1:45  
109. Joel Sweden SOK68 1:47  *****
110. iansmith United States CSU 1:48  
111. Robert Tellvik Sweden Tumba Mälarhöjden OK 1:49  *****
111. Sklenicka Czech Republic SSU 1:49  
113. BB King Sweden ÖOK 1:50  *****
113. bigluc Italy Polisportiva Masi 1:50  
115. lolob France chtiaventure 1:52  
115. ErkS Sweden Kvarnsvedens OK 1:52  
115. lostinthewood Cocos Islands AAA 1:52  
118. Blomerik England OAS 1:54  
118. Mathias Myrefelt Sweden Skarpnäcks OL 1:54  
118. Vexi Finland Rajamäen Rykmentti 1:54  
121. Champ Scotland Bsk 1:55  
122. Signe Edsen Denmark Nordvest ok 1:58  
123. Elina Sweden 2:00  
124. Rainer Germany OC Schwaben 2:02  
125. Gosha18 France VHSO 2:06  
126. Hampus Larsson Sweden FK Göingarna 2:07  
127. Trying Sweden 2:09  
127. Helder Marcolino Portugal GD4C 2:09  
129. antfor Sweden L-100 IF 2:10  
129. Storesandgubben Norway Express 2:10  *****
131. Linus Sweden 2:15  
131. Christian Tingström Sweden OK Klemmingen 2:15  
133. Thor_Norskov Denmark OK_Ost 2:16  
134. Ñåðãåé Russian Federation ÑÄÞØ 2:17  
135. hanne v Norway Byåsen IL 2:19  *****
135. Torgny Sweden Ronneby OK 2:19  
137. Lasse skare Therkildsen Denmark OK-HTF 2:20  
138. Lecramol Switzerland OLG KTV Altdorf 2:21  
139. Luka Mihaljevic Croatia Ok Vihor 2:23  
139. Charles_I Sweden OK Linne 2:23  
141. Wetheral England Ebor 2:24  
142. Gustav B Sweden OK Ravinen 2:25  
143. MH Norway NTNUI 2:26  
maybe too slow
144. LSV Ukraine O-club 2:30  
145. Sportgalning Sweden GMOK 2:31  
146. Joni Germany OC Schwaben 2:34  *****
147. IM Norway OK Linné 2:35  
148. Carlos Never Gets Lost Spain Peña Guara 2:37  
149. Baumann Edouard Switzerland SKOG 2:41  *****
okay
150. Kea Spain RiOjA-O 2:43  *****
151. cwgray United States UNO 2:45  
152. Segisteg Sweden 2:49  
152. nacho rubio Spain ALCON 2:49  *****
154. Kalugin Andrey Russian Federation strogino 2:50  
155. Thoto Germany USV TU Dresden 2:58  *****
155. Wind Runner Canada FWOC 2:58  
157. Navigatormap Brazil GEBP 3:05  
158. Stephan Germany OC Schwaben 3:11  
159. Captain Quark New Zealand Red Kiwis 3:19  
ok well there are a few things I would change. Just my opinion. Change the trees in the green, that wide pine and that smaller wide pine look tacky. cut down on sticks on the ground. Dont have grass growing in the green areas, have ferns instead. Maybe for the rough open too. Actually just have a low density of ferns all over, and just a tad higher in the green and RO. Also, I would include some of the smaller trees in the marsh area, and scattered throughout, there are no small trees in the forest. I'm sure people will disagree with these but what the hell. The rest is great! Good idea with the preview thing, I might do it for my next Ultima map.
160. karlvga95 Sweden ok kullingshof 3:58  
161. danielpinto Portugal CasteloesPNF 4:08  
162. David G Sweden IKHP 4:25  
163. Vorob'ev Vladimir Moldova Tiras-Orient 4:27  
164. Ura Russian Federation 4:51  
165. denise Austria wien 6:13  *****
166. chung chi ming Hong Kong Akinallance 7:55  
167. roma444 Russian Federation universal 8:17  
168. SiljeH Norway NTNUI 8:44  
169. bigE Canada Ottawa OC 10:59  *****
I liked the way you used grass in the different vegetations.
gvtoukc France TSN dnf  
Niklas Olsson Yemen Kopparvägen FC dnf  
wangis Sweden OLGY Slayers dnf